Evaluating an Internet Site

Title of Website: __________________________________

Full Internet Address: ___________________________________

For each of the following areas, give a score.  Then total the scores.

1. Domain Ending. 

Score: _____

3pts. =   Best possible domain ending for the information
2pts. =   OK domain ending 
0pts. =   Inappropriate domain ending
2. Authorship.  

Score: _____

4 pts. =   Author or Company name given AND evidence of expertise
2 pts. =   Name only
0 pts. =   No author, or obviously not an expert
3. Documentation. 

Score: _____

3pts. =   Includes well-documented references/bibliography
2pts. =   Some references
0pts. =   No references or bibliography. 
4. Presentation.

Score: _____

3pts. =   Easy to navigate. Neat. Professional looking. Good quality graphics
2pts =  Good, but one or two things could be better
0pts. =  Difficult, sloppy, unprofessional, rude, or "gushy"
5. Credibility of Homepage.

Score: _____

Examine the index page of a database or the home page of a website.
3pts. = Credible, appropriate, professional.  Real organizations and people who give contact information. 
1pt.   = Seems credible
0pts. = Inappropriate. Reject hype and flashiness.
6. Content.

Score: _____

4pts. = Facts presented clearly with excellent use of language. Doesn't use technical jargon to impress
2pts. = Good content, but some things could be better
0pts. =  Personal experiences only, or poor spelling/grammar, too much slang or crude/rude/lewd language.
7. Date.  

Score: _____

2pts. = Timely date
0pts. = Too old or don't know the date
8. Advertising.

Score: _____ 

3pts. = Information only, with high quality sponsors or no advertising
1pt.   = Sells a product by informing. Has quality sponsorship
0pts. = Flashy, hyped-up sponsorship or any slander/put down

Total: ____      21-25 pts = Excellent  
16-20 pts = Very Good  
11-15 pts = Proceed with Caution   
  0-10 pts = Do Not Use

This page may be reproduced for educational use.  Copyright 1999 J. Weiss